Wednesday, March 22, 2017

Sears Winona in Affton, Missouri

5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO Sears Winona model
Authenticated Sears Winona • 1930 •  5060 Lakewood Avenue, Affton, Missouri (Saint Louis County)

Sears Modern Homes catalog 1932 Sears Winona
The Winona in the 1932 Sears Modern Homes catalog
There's a great little Sears house for sale right now, in Affton, Missouri, a suburb in the southern part of Saint Louis County.  I know all about this house, because I authenticated it a couple of years ago, by tracking down its original mortgage.  The Deed of Trust was filed in 1930, in the name of Joe Friedman, and Sears trustee E. Harrison Powell signed off on the mortgage.  This weekend, my realtor brought me in to see the house in person, and I was able to find stamped lumber on a couple of the basement rafters -- the sure sign that a home was pre-cut and fitted for the homeowner, so when their bundle arrived at the work site, they would be able to get busy putting together their house!

Sears houses were sold beginning in 1908.  They had their own catalog, the Sears Modern Homes catalog, so you didn't find them mixed in with plaid skirts and nighties and boys PJs and mens galoshes offered in the big Christmas catalogs that Sears put out.  No, they merited their own catalog, but it's important to note that in the earliest years, the lumber for the houses was not pre-cut and stamped, like that of our 1930 house in Affton.  It wasn't until the 1916 catalog that Sears began offering their house kits with pre-cut lumber (and still, there were some houses that did not come pre-cut).  The kit included almost everything: pre-cut lumber for every little section of the house (stamped with identifying letter-and-number combos that helped the owner know where to put each piece of lumber); nuts and bolts and screws and nails and hinges; interior doors and exterior doors; all door hardware and locks; windows and their framing; enough flooring for a sub floor and a nice oak floor or pine floor on top; baseboard trim; roof shingles, varnish, paint; exterior shingle siding or planks or wood clapboard; screens and storm windows; kitchen cabinets; and light fixtures for all over the house. All of that was included in the base price, and then the buyer could choose the bathtub and sink and toilet and faucets they wanted, and the wiring package... even window shades. All of this came bundled together in a few separate shipments, usually via train car (so the owner had to pick everything up at the train station, and cart it to the building site).  The only things that the owner couldn't have shipped from Sears, were masonry items: bricks, concrete, and plaster. However, Sears arranged for that to be picked up at a local supplier, so it was all part of your package price. 

Sears Modern Homes catalog covers 1929 1930
Covers of the 1929 and 1930 Modern Homes catalogs, featuring "Honor Bilt" homes designed by Sears architects.
You can browse through many of the catalogs by following this link.
(1929 catalog cover courtesy of Cindy Catanazro,  scanned by Daily Bungalow)
 From The Catalog
Let's take a look at some of the interior features of the house, and how they match up to the catalog.
Sears Winona Sears Modern Homes catalog 1930
The Winona as offered in the 1930 Sears Catalog
Floor Plan
The Winona, in 1930, was offered with two similar floor plans, A, and B.  B had six rooms, and the addition of a nice bump-out section in the dining room, providing space for windows, and a double-storage window seat. The Friedmans chose the six-room B plan, as shown below, in the 1932 catalog:

Sears Winona floor plan Sears Modern Homes catalog 1932

Here is the dining room, with the two storage cubbies making up the window seat in the bump-out:

Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
Photo courtesy of the real estate listing (as are most of the interior photos of rooms here).
The wood in these storage cubbies, and around the windows, is just pristine.  It's solid, and it's in beautiful condition.  Let's take a closer look:
Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
You can see that the original oak floors are in beautiful condition throughout the house.
Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
Here's a good side shot, showing the gabled bump-out.
Another difference in the Plan B floor plan, is this beautiful, deep, wall storage unit cabinet above the space for the refrigerator, in the kitchen:

Sears Winona floor plan B

Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
Again, the wood is in beautiful condition, and these are solid cabinet doors.
Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
Here's the kitchen, with that extra storage cabinet over the fridge, and three beautifully-trimmed wood windows.
Here's the view into the dining room from the living room.  I was just looking at interior photos of another Sears house recently, and that house had the same size and shape of the curved entryway between rooms.
Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
Here we see the living room, with two nice big windows, and the Craftsman-style front door that enters in right next to the doorway to the front bedroom.
Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO

Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
From the 1930 Honor Bilt Modern Homes catalog.
I do notice that the three sort of bumps under the window panes are thinner and longer than the catalog shows-- I wonder if the door look changed a bit with the size?
Throughout the house, there are gorgeous, solid-wood doors, of one of the better choices from the catalog.  If you're used to a modern, subdivision house with hollow-core vinyl doors, you won't believe the difference in the quality of these doors.
Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
As offered in the 1930 Honor Bilt Building Materials catalog (source).
Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
One of the bedrooms, with two nice windows, and a solid-wood door to the closet.

Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
Here we have the beautiful door that leads to the basement, in the kitchen.

Sears Winona 5060 Lakewood Avenue St. Louis MO
The staircase to the attic space has its own door. The attic spans the entire length and width of the house, and was perfectly clean and ready to be finished into a great loft space for a family room or large master bedroom.

As mentioned above in the little snippet from the catalog about the B plan, the house comes standard with the Shefton design door hardware, and it can be seen on every door in the house.
Sears Shefton door hardware 1930 sears building materials catalog
From the 1930 Honor Bilt Building Materials catalog (source)

Sears Shefton door hardware 1930 sears winona
Sears Shefton door hadware.

Sears Shefton door hardware 1930 sears winona
Sears Shefton door hardware.
Another characteristic of a solid-wood home, is a tongue-in-groove ceiling on the front porch, and our Winona in Affton has that.  It could use a new coat of paint, but you can't beat the quality:
Sears WInona 5060 Lakewood Ave St. Louis Missouri

Quality Materials and Quality Construction
Because Sears, as a department store, was marketed as a store providing economically-priced goods that a working-class family could afford, some people assume that Sears homes were "budget-quality" homes. But, the exact opposite is true.  Sears homes are sturdy, solidly-built homes, with quality components, with much thought to the quality of the design of the construction.  Let's look at a page from my 1930 catalog, to see how construction qualities are described:

Sears Modern Homes catalog 1930



Sears Modern Homes were marketed as "Honor Bilt" homes. 

There was also a more budget-friendly line, referred to as "standard built".  

Sears Modern Homes catalog 1930
Missouri was part of the Western territory, so most of our Affton Winona's building components came from the Cairo, Illinois Sears factory. 

Sears Modern Homes catalog 1930
Sears was proud to describe the quality of the wood shipped for their homes-- all solid, No. 1 Yellow Pine, clear Cypress, and White Pine.  Floors were made of clear Maple or Clear Oak, with Oak or Birch trim.  Trim pieces were shipped from the Norwood (Cincinnati), Ohio "Norwood Sash & Door" plant, owned by Sears.  For this reason, we often see shipping labels on the back of window or door trim, with that name.

Sears Modern Homes catalog 1930
Quality sub floor and finish floor woods are described in the catalog.

Sears Modern Homes catalog 1930

Pre-cut wood was a big part of the Sears kit-home concept.  Kit-home companies always claimed that the buyer saved a good sum of money, and time, by avoiding on-site measuring and cutting.  Sears boards came cut-to-size, and labeled to help the construction crew know what pieces went where.  A sizable leather-bound manual came with the kit, and pieces of lumber were stamped on the ends, and on the face of each board, with a letter and 3-digit number.  I've read that C boards were 2x6 , and D boards were 2x8 boards.
Sears Modern Homes catalog 1930 marked lumber
One of the reasons that I was excited to be able to go inside of the Affton Winona, was because I was hoping to find some stamped lumber.  I've never seen any in person. Stamped lumber is a definite authenticating factor, so if we suspect that a house is a Sears house, and we find stamped lumber, we are thrilled.  In the case of the Affton house, I had already authenticated the house as a Sears house, through the existence of a mortgage deed through Sears, but, nonetheless, I was super excited to see stamped lumber in person. Annette, my realtor, and I, looked all over the rafters in the (very clean) attic, but couldn't find any marks.  As luck would have it, though, in the basement, I found two boards with the unmistakeable Sears stamp: a letter and a number combo on each of the two boards.
stamped lumber in a sears house
This looks to be C...88. I don't know if the space contained another number originally, or not.

marked lumber in a sears house
Here, we clearly have B 327 stamped, in figures about an inch or so high.
The basement of the Affton Winona is very clean, so I didn't mind looking around to find some marked lumber. The first spot I tried, was under the basement staircase, as, for some reason, this is often where homeowners find still-visible stamped lumber.  Unfortunately, this was the only spot that had some cobwebs, so I aimed my searches back up to the floor joists...and that's where I found my two spots of marked lumber.


On the exterior, unfortunately, we can no longer see the wood siding of the house, as it has been, sadly, covered over with vinyl siding.  That's my only complaint about the house, but some homeowners feel that its less maintenance.  Right now, our cute little vinylized Winona needs a good power washing, but that wouldn't take much time or effort.  On the front porch, however, the original wood support columns are still in place (wooo hooo!) -- and they are a sturdy support structure:
Sears Modern Homes catalog 1930
From the 1930 catalog.

Sears WInona 5060 Lakewood Avenue Affton MO
And here we have the original support columns on the porch.

Sears WInona 5060 Lakewood Avenue Affton MO
Oh, sure, they're a little dirty, but a little power washing or painting would fix that.

Sears WInona 5060 Lakewood Avenue Affton MO
This is what the house looked like after a fresh paint job, I suspect, in earlier sales photos, from 2012.

Sears WInona 5060 Lakewood Avenue Affton MO
Nice and clean, back in 2012.
Who Lived Here
Joseph Friedman is the man who took out the mortgage to buy this Winona from Sears. He took out a $3,900 mortgage, and my guess is that this covered not only the kit, but some, or all, of the construction costs as well (while some folks built their Sears homes themselves, Sears always advertised that they were ready and willing to connect you with a local contractor, as part of your overall price).
Sears home construction division ad
Here's an ad in the classified section of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, March 22, 1931, page 47.
Sears home construction division ad
Sears home construction division ad
This ad appeared in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch on May 17, 1931, on page 48. In most markets, Sears did not offer solid-brick homes, but in St. Louis, brick center of the midwest, they must have decided that they needed to change their marketing strategy.  In the city of St. Louis, brick was the required building material, so Sears heavily touted their "We'll-design-to-suit" plans.  They also mention "Planned-Financed-Built" by Sears, Roebuck and Co.  
Joe lived in Affton, Missouri, and I had a heck of a time figuring out where this house was, because one of the Joe Friedmans in the family actually lived on a nearby street (right next door to another Sears house, the Clyde model), and another, the father of the family was renting nearby, in 1930.   Through a good bit of searching the St. Louis County Assessor's website, and online city directories and census records for St. Louis, I finally figured out that, though Joe Friedman signed the mortgage papers for this house, it was not he, but rather Clarence Friedman, who lived in the Winona at 5060 Lakewood Avenue.  In the Friedman family, father Joseph Friedman had a son named Joseph, and a son named Clarence.  One of the Joseph's must have either gifted Clarence this house, or signed the mortgage for him.  Clarence was six years younger than Joe, and when Clarence married Clara, they must have needed a home... and this was it!

The Friedman family originally lived in Beauvais Township, part of Ste. Genevieve County, a river area about an hour south of the Affton area of St. Louis,  and it has strong French settler origins-- though the Friedman family has German roots. Joseph S. Friedman was a farmer, born in Texas to a German father and Missouri-born mother.  He married Missourian Cecilia (who had a German mother, and a Missouri-born father!), and, in 1920, the Ste. Genevieve census tells us that there were five children in the household: Mary, Joseph, Clarence, Louis, and Wilma.  By the 1930 census, though, the family was in St. Louis, with son Joseph owning a house in South St. Louis, father Joseph renting nearby, and Clarence still living at home, at age 20.


joseph friedman cecilia friedman ste genevieve mo 1920 census

joseph friedman cecilia friedman ste genevieve mo 1920 census


Later city directory and census records put the two brothers in Affton (earlier known as Gardenville, and so referred to in the directories that way, or with the abbreviation Ga ), with Joe living on Waldo Avenue, and Clarence and his wife Clara, living in the Winona on Lakewood Avenue.

sears clyde model 1925 catalog
The Sears Clyde in the 1925 catalog.
However it came to be, Clarence and Clara Friedman lived their lives for many, many years, in the Sears Winona in Affton, Missouri.  Clarence was a mechanic at Sunset Auto Company (possibly what many of us know of as Sunset Ford?), and Clara was a home maker.
joseph friedman clarence friedman clara friedman cecilia friedman anna friedman st louis city directory 1943
Here is the 1943 St. Louis city directory, showing the Joseph S/Cecelia Friedmans living on Union Road, in Lemay; the Joseph Jr./Anna Friedmans, living on Waldo Avenue in Gardenville (Affton) [he was a postal clerk]; and the Clarence/Clara Friedmans living in the Winona, on Lakewood Avenue, in Gardenville (Affton).

clarence friedman and clara friedman in 1958 st louis city directory
The 1958 St. Louis city directory shows that Clarence Frideman was working as a mechanic, at Sunset Auto, and still living in the Winona.
Clarence and Clara were a couple for 65 years, living most of that in the Winona on Lakewood Avenue.  Clarence served in the U. S. Army from 1943-45, and it looks like they never had any children, but lived long lives, he until the age of 92, and she until the age of 98.  Both Clarence and Clara are buried together, at Jefferson Barracks National Cemetary
clarence friedman obituary
Source: Find a Grave

clara friedman obituary
Source: Find a Grave
clarence friedman grave stone jefferson barracks cemetary

clara friedman grave stone jefferson barracks cemetary
As is the custom at a national cemetary, a husband and wife are buried in the same grave,
 and their names are carved one on each side of the gravestone. 

One Last Note on the Winona
By the way, the Winona evolved over the years, ending its long run in the Sears catalog, with this model that the Friedmans lived in.  However, it was first offered in 1913, as the No. 205, and had a bit of a different look, and a smaller floor plan, with chunky porch columns.  It continued with that look through the years, until at least the 1926 catalog. The 1928 catalog is the first year that it is offered with the look that the Friedmans' home has.

sears winona early version sears no. 205
The earliest version of what later was called the Winona: the No. 205, on page 67 of Houses By Mail.
sears winona 1925 catalog early version 2 floor plans
The Winona in the 1925 Sears Modern Homes catalog.
Here is an endangered (or possibly now-demolished) older-version Sears Winona, in Dayton, Ohio. You can read more about it, and see more photos, in this Sears Houses in Ohio blog post by Cindy Catanzaro.
sears winona dayton ohio

sears winona dayton ohio

And, finally, here is a lovely old Winona that is being lovingly restored by the couple who write this blog, Eleven02Glen:
sears winona eleven02glen blog
Looks great to me in either color scheme!

If you're interested in more information about the sale of this house, you can visit the Zillow listing here

1 comment:

  1. What a fascinating post! These homes are lovely. Thanks for sharing everything!
    Robin

    ReplyDelete

Your comment will appear after it has been previewed and approved by the blog author. Thanks for your interest!